Quantcast
Channel: Thread Criticism of the Editors on 'Bleacher Report Community Forum'
Browsing all 20 articles
Browse latest View live

re:

I wonder what PJ Ross' implication is with that complaint. That 14 year olds don't have/aren't capable of having any idea of what constitues good writing, bad writing, or how to improve any specific...

View Article



re:

Thanks very much to Tab for taking the time to raise his concerns. Before I respond to Tab's specific points, let me state for the record that all B/R Staff Editors and editing Interns are subject to...

View Article

re:

This complaint comes from Tab Bamford. It has been refiled under the "Criticism of the Editors" topic for organizational purposes.Quoting Tab: I don't complain much, if ever, but....I know that a...

View Article

re:

I'm glad I could clarify the matter, Emma—and I'm grateful for both your passion and your understanding. — Ryan  --Ryan AlbertiManaging EditorBleacher Report Team

View Article

re:

Understood, and absolutely fair enough. Thanks, Ryan...

View Article


re:

Thanks to Emma, MSchottey, and PJ for fleshing out the details of the age question. As noted above, candidates for B/R's entry-level editorial Intern Program must be at least undergraduate journalism...

View Article

re:

Well, PJ, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one. You can continue making a deal of something which, as far as I'm concerned, bears little to no relevance at all, and I can continue to...

View Article

re:

Thanks Shottey, I think you explained what I was trying to say with a bit more clarity than I did. It's just a matter of experience, like you said.Sure, young kids might know the basics, but if this...

View Article


re:

What PJ may or may not have in political correctness aside, I'm glad the new editorial model is in place. By 14 I was on my second writing job and in charge of "editing" my schools' paper. That said,...

View Article


re:

In general I have enjoyed all of my interactions with the editors. I had one issue though, i will not name names but I received an edit a couple of days after I had posted a piece and it had actually...

View Article

re:

I wonder what PJ Ross' implication is with that complaint. That 14 year olds don't have/aren't capable of having any idea of what constitues good writing, bad writing, or how to improve any specific...

View Article

re:

The following piece of criticism comes from B/R user PJ Ross. It was re-filed here after originally being posted under a discussion topic entitled "Editor's (sic) need an age requirement."[Begin PJ's...

View Article

re:

Thanks to both Dan and SilverFox for raising their concerns. To respond to them one at a time...@Dan:You're right that there are certain times when we don't have many (or sometimes any) editors on...

View Article


re:

 I thank most of the editors here who do a competent job of making corrections and improvements in my articles. However, a few of the other so-called editors here evidently need to learn the difference...

View Article

re:

I guess my only issue is that on occasion it takes awhile to get any editing done. It's not often, but I have identified a few different points in the week that I hate publishing articles because I...

View Article


re:

Well said on all fronts, MSchottey. As noted in our Editorial Guidelines, B/R editors are instructed to defer to authorial voice as much as possible—but we don't always manage to strike a perfect...

View Article

re:

Overall my experience with the editors has been a positive--a special shoutout to Mosang Miles and Dann Gaymer who have gone over many of my articles with a fine tooth comb. Ryan Droege is also on...

View Article


re:

test test

View Article

re:

In a preexisting post, Hotnuke and Tab Bamford have raised concerns about revisions to the headlines of their...

View Article

Article 0

B/R editors are intensively trained and closely supervised in our work—but we’re not perfect.When we make mistakes as editors, it’s important that we learn from them. Before that can happen, though,...

View Article
Browsing all 20 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images